Liverpool should have had a penalty against Arsenal, independent panel rules
The Premier League's Key Match Incidents panel says Jurrien Timber's tug on Alexander Isak's shirt at Anfield was a foul that both the referee and VAR got wrong.
Liverpool were wrongly denied a penalty in their 1-0 home defeat by Arsenal, the Premier League's independent Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel has concluded.
The flashpoint came midway through the first half at Anfield on 1 November. Arsenal were already in front through Kai Havertz, whose goal would settle the game, when Bradley Barcola swung a cross into the box. Alexander Isak was shaping to head it when Jurrien Timber grabbed his shirt and pulled him back.
Referee Andy Madley let play go on, and VAR Stuart Attwell decided against sending him to the pitchside monitor.
The verdict
The five-person panel voted 4-1 that Madley should have pointed to the spot. By a narrower 3-2 margin, it also decided Attwell should have stepped in, ruling the miss a clear and obvious error.
Not everyone agreed. One panellist felt the hold was too brief to stop Isak getting to the ball, while two others argued that judging its impact was too subjective to justify a VAR intervention.
Should Isak have gone down?
Isak stayed on his feet, and that quickly became the talking point. Liverpool boss Andoni Iraola was adamant it was a clear penalty and said the decision would have been different had his striker hit the deck: “If he does, they call the penalty 100 per cent.” Asked if he would now tell Isak to go down in future, he said he would.
Virgil van Dijk questioned why a player should need to make a fuss when there are dozens of cameras covering every angle. Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta said he had not watched the incident back.
On Sky Sports, Jamie Carragher, Ian Wright and Daniel Sturridge all argued Isak should not have had to exaggerate the contact to win the decision, while Gary Neville found the striker's lack of protest unusual. Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher said the referee's angle showed very little, but the replay VAR had access to was far more damning, and suggested Timber had taken a risk and got away with it.
Mac Allister booking backed
The panel did side with the officials on the game's other big moment. Late in the second half, Alexis Mac Allister went down clutching his face after coming head to head with Noni Madueke. VAR checked for a red card, but Madueke stayed on and Mac Allister was booked instead.
The KMI panel unanimously agreed that was correct, describing the contact as negligible and Mac Allister's reaction as exaggerated.
The Golazo Junkie take
The ruling changes nothing in the table, and Arsenal keep the three points. But it does sharpen a familiar frustration: when a forward stays on his feet and tries to play on, the officials too often decide he wasn't really fouled. If a stretched-arm shirt pull seven yards out is only a penalty when the attacker falls over, the game is rewarding the wrong behaviour. Iraola's “go down next time” instruction is a perfectly logical response to that, and that's exactly the problem.
Elsewhere, the panel also ruled that Ipswich Town should have had a penalty in their 2-2 draw with Hull City on 3 October, when Nobel Mendy held Dara O'Shea at a corner with the game still goalless.
Additional reporting: Sky Sports.
